Thursday, 11 August 2016

A muser's tale

As an 11 year old boy who had been presented with “an alligator’s voice box”, an Aboriginal stone axe head and various ‘interesting rocks’ as curios, my arrivals at the entrances of Sydney's Museum of Applied Arts and Sciences, the Australia Museum and the Art Gallery were filled with all kinds of expectations. 

Moreover, as a ‘bush-kid’ from Mullumbimby and I arrived to these places mostly by tram having travelled to Sydney by steam train. So both the journey and the arrival were always destined to be memorable. 

Except for one exhibit at MAAS, a Scythian bridleCAT# 14299 – I remember relatively little. About the bridle however, I did wonder why anyone would put such a thing on a horse – thinking about the horses at home it didn't make much sense at all. And of course there was the Strasburg Clock . 

I recall my first musingplace visits as being somewhat overwhelming but I was to return to them whenever there was an opportunity. 

Between that first time and the age of 16 I travelled to Sydney three or four times. That first visit was a sensory blast as after the museums there was Vaucluse House and Taronga Parka bush kid discovers musing. Mullumbimby didn't have anything like a museum in those days but Lismore did. Lismore’s museum and art gallery, albeit almost as far away mentally as Sydney's in opportunity terms, was a modest affair but still worth a visit when and if 'in town'family histories of a sort could be found there.

I do remember quite well a yellow rush seated chair in Lismore plus a whole lot of Aboriginal stone artifacts along with various 'local' mineral specimens. The 'yellow chair' stands out in so much as it's image seems to have become stuck as I've become aware of things that I couldn't possibly have known about at 11– Van Gogh's 1888 painting of the yellow chair in particular and the coincidences to do with 'New Italy' on the Richmond River.

My newly graduated Sydney school teacher cousin had given herself a job to do on that visit of mine and she left relatively few stones unturned. Somehow she managed to get me to the Jenolan Caves and to a bush walk of a kind near Katoomba in addition to the city musing. During those couple of weeks, festooned as they were with trips here and there by ferry tram and trains, I got to see new things rather than ‘old relatives’

Within five years of that first visit to Sydney I was living and working in Sydney and I was to become a very regular visitor to MAAS Harris St. given that entry was free and that as a part of my apprenticeship course I was to attend drawing classes there as well. In retrospect these visits were designed to subliminally broaden the minds of us ‘tradie apprentices’

Beyond that I became a regular muser as I took on additional study at the National Art School and maintained a schedule of musingplace visiting that included the Mitchell Library and the Botanical Gardens. Yet as other things take precedence in one’s life musingplaces tend to slip into the background. Then you take your children along to broaden their minds. Also, when you get to travel, and you get into the habit again, musingplaces figure in itineraries. Alongside that you get to have students and trainees who you encourage to visit to see this or that first hand. 

The more widely you travel the broader your musing experiences become. The number you become aware of grows with each journey as does your expectations – and you get to meet more and more collectors. Then you find your own and your colleagues work being collected by musingplaces. Along with that you find yourself working with musingplaces in the delivery of exhibition projects etc. 

In addition to all this you find yourself on committees and panels with musingplaces on the agenda one way or another. Somehow museums, art galleries, heritage buildings, libraries and other manifestations of musingplaces become culturally embedded in whatever it is that you do. 

Rather than even out, the opportunities to get into musingplaces 24/7 grow as the Internet figures more largely. Yet somehow as expectations grow delivery upon them seems to fall away. 

After a wet weekend you know the world has changed when you overhear a conversation in a coffee shop about going to museums. You overhear a couple of grandparents chatting about the weather, looking after grandchildren and keeping them from being bored. The conversation goes along much as one might expect, except for a loudish exclamation 'and museums ... they're no longer an option on wet Sundays … as it was in our day ...'

One grandparent even reported trying to get the children mustered to go to the museum and finding being "totally uncooperative and resistant". Apparently the children absolutely refused to leave the house because “our computer has more interesting things on it than the museum has.” 

Nowadays older muser find this to be true too it seemed from the follow on conversation. 

Add caption
Speaking personally, I often go to museums and art galleries these days as much to see who else is there as much anything else. Quite often visitors are outnumbered by the staff most of whom are standing around making sure that the visitors are not doing anything untoward. From time to time you have to wonder when the day will come when robots will be filling this role and many others at the same time given that technology may very soon allow for that. 

Anyway, much of my musing is ‘Internet facilitated’ and even though my physical musing laboratory is at the bottom of the hill upon which I live, I’m not constrained by my physical geography – and haven't been for quite a while

Quite often I can find what I’m seeking online if I've got something in particular in mind. My computer means I can usually visit without the need to navigate the in-house cultural landscape. As often as not a great deal more can be gleaned online. It’s increasingly frustrating to witness many musingplaces trying to hang on to the past when the ‘musing experience’, potentially, has so much more to offer. The possibilities of the status quo were over yesterday but musing in the presence of real things is still unequalled.

_________________________
Ray Norman – Artist, Metalsmith, Networker, Independent Researcher, Currently a Launcestonian, Cultural Theorist, Cultural Geographer and a hunter of Deep Histories ... Ray is Co-Director of zingHOUSEunlimited, a lifestyle design enterprise and network offering a range of services linked to contemporary cultural production and cultural research. Ray is also engaged with the nudgelbah institute as a cultural geographer. That institute's purpose is to be network of research networks and to be a diverse vehicle through which place oriented scholarship and cultural endeavours can be acknowledged, honoured and promoted.... LINK

Wednesday, 10 August 2016

Citizens And Curatorship

OVERHEARD CONVERSATION

"Why does all curating need to be done in-house and have a lot too much to do with gatekeeping?" ... Tandra Vale

"Is because the SSC (Secret Society of Curators) want to keep  each other in work?" ... Unidentified student


Click here to go to source
A PAPER

Recognising the citizen curator
Rebecca O’Neill, University of Hull 

"As more projects aim to disseminate information and digital objects online, the impetus for both staff and the public to curate objects within personal and collective narratives is quite strong. This paper look to recognise the citizen curator, a motivated individual who spends time engaging with projects such as Wikipedia or BBC Your Paintings or initiates their own project(s), marking a turning point in the overall understanding of what it means to curate and most importantly who curates. The ability to identify these citizen curators is a direct consequence of the social web as their activities have become increasingly visible as the capacity to share, organise, aggregate and distribute information on line has increased. They exist within a spectrum of curation that incorporates seemingly ‘traditional’ forms in museums and galleries to more challenging methods of computer driven or crowd sourced curation. 

The acknowledgement, understanding and incorporation such citizen curators into institutional curatorial practice opens up new and exciting areas of engagement and participation for the heritage industry. It brings a novel set of tools to the debate surrounding the involvement of larger communities in the mission and direction of a museum or gallery. As more organisations throw open their collections and allow them to be ‘set free’ on the wider web through initiatives like The Mechanical Curator from the British Library, how these digital objects are understood, collated, aggregated and ultimately curated by the wider public could be a space for collaboration and participation on an unprecedented scale. The challenge now is to place the citizen curator within an enlarged understanding of curation to further not only online or digital curation but curatorial practice as a whole." ... [LINK]
Click here to go to source
Art Talk with Jo-Anne Birnie Danzker of the Frye Art Museum 

Question to ,Jo-Anne Birnie Danzker: Can you tell us about the process of curation? Where do you begin? How do you know it's "complete?" 

JO-ANNE BIRNIE DANZKER: For much of my professional life, I thought of curating as having a beginning (an idea or a passion that insisted on being realized); a process (research, extended conversations with the artists); and a denouement or culmination (the exhibition, its accompanying publication, and its reception by the public and the press). Because of this drive towards denouement, and the desire to produce a “definitive” interpretation of the subject, it would be rare for me to undertake a second exhibition, or a third, with the same artist or artists. In recent years, however, I have come to understand curating and my own role in a very different manner. I now see curatorial projects as conversations that begin long before an exhibition, and continue long after an exhibition closes. In other words, my perception of my role has changed dramatically. Curating for me is now never “complete.”...


CLICK HERE TO GO TO SOURCE

REFERENCES
V&A on Curatorship ...  Click Here
• Citizen Curator: discover Leith's artistic heritage ... video ... Click Here
• Washington Post: Citizen Curators' Two Cents: Worth Every Penny ... Click Here
• “Never Heard of ‘Em”: Why Citizen Curators (not Daddy’s Money) Should Decide Who Gets to Be an Artist ... Click Here
• A GOOGLEsearch:  ... Click Here
• CITIZEN CURATOR ON FACEbook ... https://www.facebook.com/Citizen-Curator-241129699394700/

Tuesday, 9 August 2016

Musingplaces And The Emerging Paradigm

CLICK HERE TO GO TO SOURCE
As audiences grow so too musingplaces Communities of Ownership & Interest along with  employment opportunities. However, it has to be asked how sustainable are musingplaces imagined as  Micawberish COST CENTRES dependent on  conscripted 'public funding'? The other question that needs to be asked is, when opportunities do 'turn up' how ready are musingplaces to take them up and deliver on the efficiency dividends as they become available?

CLICK HERE TO GO TO SOURCE

Online Accountability And Efficiency Dividends

CLICK ON IMAGE TO ENLARGE
Accountability standards across the 'musingplace sector' is best described as being uneven. Arguably the pace of change has left musingplace policy determiners (Trustees, Governors, etc.), and the administrators of the policy settings they put in place, somewhat behind the game. Nonetheless, the Internet and digital technologies can come together to deliver on accountability reporting in ways unimaginable say two decades ago – or even less time than that.

The National Museum of Australia Media Release Archive serves not only as a very useful research tool but also a mechanism for documenting performance outcomes. Likewise, the archive offers an opportunity to deliver on the efficiency dividends available to the musingplace's operation.

As things change and enable the delivery of more with less, musingplaces can become more accountable via the implementation of new and emerging strategies that enable to exploit these developments. Click here to visit the NMA Media Archive.

Musing Shelf 601


Musingplaces have shelves and shelves are for storing stuff. So it is no surprise that almost suddenly stuff starts telling little stories and sometime big stories. Likewise it is unsurprising that the ordinary is extraordinary and that if you come to a bunch of stuff with a rule to muse upon you need not move beyond a shelf with stuff on it. It is not necessary to leave one musingplace to visit another unless it has shelves with stuff on them and most importantly enough space – that's mindspace – to see stuff through your own eyes, your own memories, your own imanginings – and on your own and by yourself.

Monday, 8 August 2016

Musingplace Relationship Chart

Click on the image to enlarge
CONTEX This chart is based on the proposition that a 'musingplace' stands alone as an entity rather than exist under the aegis of some other entity – Government (Federal, State, Local), University, organisation, business. An analogy here would be any not-for-profit incorporated association that is incorporated to protect its membership and ensure its accountability as a not-for-profit 'operation'.

Typically,'public musingplaces' operate under the aegis of 'government' as statutory authorities, a special committee, department, etc. There is increasing evidence that while this provides 'notional accountability' functional accountability is not automatically guaranteed.

In the end this does not offer those who 'invest ' in musinplaces in all their machinations:
• Any guarantee that their investments in the form of taxes, rates, donations, sponsorships etc. have been applied to their intended purpose;
 Any guarantee that the operation meets any of the implied obligations taken on by trustees, management, staff, collection managers, et al;
 Any guarantee that the operation conforms to any 'best practice standards' even though they may be articulated in published plans etc;
 Any guarantee that stated policies are being implemented in the ways members of incorporated associations can via their constitutions.

The accountability implied by democratic elections does not functionally provide a musingplace's Community of Ownership and Interest (COI) with the reasonable assurances they deserve and have a right to expect.

It seems that under current Federal and/or State government law the kinds of guarantees and assurances that apply to 'incorporated associations' apply to musingplaces unless they are of course incorporated as standalone organisations.


EXPLANATION OF TERMS
 Community of Ownership and Interest: (compound noun/proposition) an all-inclusive collective/community of people, individuals and groups, who in any way have multi layered relationships with a place or cultural landscape and/or the operation of an institution, organisation or establishment – typically a network ... usage and context.– cultural geography; civic and environmental planning; and community administration ... [LINK]

Saturday, 6 August 2016

Windows, Collecting And Musing


John Cage said that “the first question I ask myself when something doesn't seem to be beautiful is why do I think it's not beautiful. And very shortly you discover that there is no reason.” He also told us that "if something is boring after two minutes, try it for four. If still boring, then eight. Then sixteen. Then thirty-two. Eventually one discovers that it is not boring at all." It turns out that they are two good quotes to remember when musing on anything anywhere anywhere and in particular when looking out a window. There is this idea that is also deeply embedded in the the way we see the world that we know that in the progress is impossible without change.  Along with it comes the idea that if we cannot change our minds we cannot change anything. Standing at a window and looking out, and taking note, gives us all the evidence we will ever need.

Windows And Musing


In mythology, the Muses were nine goddesses who symbolized the arts and sciences and who gave meaning to the world. Now, a muse is something, often a person, who serves as an inspiration. Quite often filmmakers talk about an actor being a muse — meaning the actor inspired a movie. Writers, painters, musicians, and cultural producers have muses. Musing is to do with thinking deeply. If you muse its serious. It takes longer than a few seconds 'to muse'. Many muse upon an idea for year upon year. As it is with 'the dawn' musing means, or can mean, something 'becoming light' or it 'becoming clear,' like when it 'dawns on you that you' that you hadn't perceived something. In that case, you can suddenly see what you did wrong, like at the dawn of a new day, when it is no longer dark and you can see, literally. Windows, are for musing and letting in the light and each morning is a new beginning. Collectors understand this and quite a few stand at windows.

Friday, 5 August 2016

WUNDERKAMMER4051|2725-15300


Not all musingplaces have and income stream from the public purse yet they are there and they are the repositories of 'cultural property'. Somehow, and sometimes, the collections in such musingplaces are at least as important as the ones 'the public' subsidise if not more so. The curators know their subjects quite well even when they do not have PhDs etc. Their placedness is often secret for security reasons and very often the start out as so much 'worthless crap' wind up in 'public collections'. Not unusually, they are ascribed values beyond measure largely because some public musingplace 'collection keeper' missed their value – fiscal, social, cultural

WUNDERKAMMER4051|2725-15300 is such a collection within such a musingplace.

Tuesday, 2 August 2016

11 Reasons To Think About Changing Public Musingplaces In The 21st Century

Musingplaces in the 21st Century are hopefully quite different places to the 16th Century Kunstkammers and Wunderkammers that their foundations are rooted within. Just about everything except human curiosity has changed yet public musingplaces in particular somehow seek to cling to a status quo established a rather long time ago.

These places are commonly understood as 'museums and/or galleries' but in reality they are more diverse than that would suggest. It also seems that such places are more than important to communities and their ability to sustain the fundamentals of humanity. More on this can be accessed by clicking here

Just about every aspect of musingplace governance, management, funding, sponsorship etc should now be on the table for discussion. It is well outside the scope of this set of 'musings on musingplaces' to deeply interrogate the subject. Nonetheless, it is clear that so much has changed, and is changing, that to ignore all this would be assuming that all is well in this sector of endeavour. 

Anyway, everything is not all that it could be, or might be, even if there is a lot of 'good stuff' going on. 


Click Here for a more expansive look at the issues